The Importance of Simplifying Decision-Making

In a world with an overflowing number of options for everything, the act of choosing can feel both liberating and paralysing. From choosing a service provider to the right item to purchase, the sheer abundance of choices can actually lead to overwhelm and indecision. There are two key concepts that offer us insight on how this happens: Hick’s Law and the Paradox of Choice.

What is Hick’s Law?

Also known as the Hick-Hyman Law, this concept is named after a British and American psychologist team of William Edmund Hick and Ray Hyman and dates back to 1952. It focuses on the reaction time of an individual based on how many objects or stimuli they’re given. They found that when there are more stimuli to respond to, the reaction time to respond to any of them gets reduced.

An example of how this plays out on a website is the number of CTAs that appear on a single page. If there are multiple Calls To Action, a user will take more time to process and react than if it is limited to two clear and distinct buttons.

What is the Paradox of Choice?

Whilst Hick’s Law focuses on the mechanics of decision time, the Paradox of Choice puts focus on the emotional state of the user when presented with too many options. This concept comes from American psychologist Barry Schwartz in his book titled The Paradox of Choice – Why More Is Less published in 2004. It argues that an abundance of choice can lead to anxiety, dissatisfaction, and regret.

When presented with a vast array of options, people often experience:

Decision Paralysis: Too many options can overwhelm individuals, making it harder to decide at all.

Regret and Self-Blame: After making a choice, individuals may feel regret or question whether they made the best decision, especially when other attractive options were available.

Diminished Satisfaction: Even if the chosen option is objectively good, the awareness of what was left behind can detract from overall satisfaction.

Schwartz’s research indicates that reducing choice can improve a user’s wellbeing or satisfaction. Limiting a product lineup or offering more curated selections can ease the burden of decision making on a user and increase their overall experience.

Practical Ways to Simplify Decision-Making

Streamline Design

Enhance usability by limiting choices per screen or menu. Clear categorisation and prioritisation of options help users focus on what matters most.

Curated Recommendations

Retailers can guide customers by highlighting a “top pick” or “best value” option, reducing decision fatigue.

Decision Defaults

Providing a default choice simplifies the process for users who may feel overwhelmed, while still allowing flexibility for those who want to explore further.

*****

Understanding how giving users an overabundance of choice can reduce reaction times, as well as increase stress and decision-fatigue, is the first step to improving user experience. By balancing variety with simplicity, we can create websites that empower users to confidently make decisions and enjoy the outcomes more fully.